Plastic Plates Put in Garbage Cart Can Not be Recycled Plastic plates are made from low-grade plastic that can’t be recycled. Dispose of plastic plates in the trash. Not Suitable for Second Meal Don’t wash and reuse disposable plastic plates. The plastic degrades and becomes unsafe to eat from. Durable plastic plates can be reused safely. Ways to Reduce Choose Reusables Instead Substitute reusable plates and containers for disposable plastic plates. For gatherings, consider asking family members and friends to bring their own reusable tableware and left-overs containers. Ways to Reuse Save for Crafts Use plates for craft time! Here’s a creative way to make wall art with plates.